Lots of people would, and lots of people would leave after a month. I think it's just that the owners don't want to be those guys who restart servers every couple of months, which is understandable. Some people lose respect for servers that constantly do that. If people gave it a shot they would see that this is one of the most stable and well-designed private servers. If you had an account here once I would recommend coming back perhaps with a few friends.
Bookmarks