What is better shard +8 or cleaver +9?

[waitnbleed]

what is better shard +8 101 ap / 80 poison or cleaver +9 102 ap / 90 poison


i dont care the looks

[Lvzbel]

is easy to tell
cleaver has 1 more ap and 10 more posion damage but cleaver has less durability and youll have to repair more often

[G0D]

cleaver +9 ftw :wub:

[h3h3h3]

I have heard that weapon level affects damage, and that they would both hit around the same.

I think i would probably use a shard +8 because the difference in AP is marginal, and I don't like to look noobish.

[G0D]

lol u would say about the looks wouldnt u :lol: :lol: :lol:

[Josh]

Some gut did a test with a bardish +8 and glave +6 or 7 cant remeber, but the bardish had more ap but ended up doing average of 100-200 less to a lard orc

[:pic:]

well 1ap more or less on rogue weapon wont be effct ur total ap so better go with shard

[PADDY]

a bardish +9 did like 100 - 200 more damge than a raptor +8 per hit in pvp

and that had less ap than the raptor... the poison made all the difference

[G0D]

i think 1ap more = 40ap or 20ap on ur stats i dunno :/

[oncemore]

Originally posted by PADDY
a bardish +9 did like 100 - 200 more damge than a raptor +8 per hit in pvp

and that had less ap than the raptor... the poison made all the difference

LOL

[MillionVoices]

its obvious the Cleaver +9 is superior to shard +8 .

[PADDY]

Originally posted by oncemore+--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(oncemore)</div>

<!--QuoteBegin-PADDY

a bardish +9 did like 100 - 200 more damge than a raptor +8 per hit in pvp

and that had less ap than the raptor... the poison made all the difference

LOL[/b]

?

i tried the two... why else do you think people complained i hit too hard? :P

[aligator]

stiletto +10 :wub:

[oncemore]

Originally posted by PADDY+--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(PADDY)</div>

Originally posted by oncemore@
<!--QuoteBegin-PADDY

a bardish +9 did like 100 - 200 more damge than a raptor +8 per hit in pvp

and that had less ap than the raptor... the poison made all the difference

LOL

?

i tried the two... why else do you think people complained i hit too hard? :P[/b]

Raptor+8 is 187/80
Bardish+9 is 184/90

I can believe that the extra 10 elemental can make up for the loss of 3ap, but adding an extra 200dmg on top? rofflecopter. Then again, i guess it depends on who you tested, if it was a naked duffed mage and your spamming 2k dmg, a 200dmg increase isn't a very high percent. :P

But if your hitting a warrior for 500dmg with a raptor, and then hit 700dmg with bardish, haha. xD

[ChosenAngel]

Originally posted by aligator
stiletto +10 :wub:

sword breaker +10 u mean h43r: