A few weeks ago I let a clannie who had recently been hacked borrow an MS+7 and then later an II+7. Then a couple hours after he got the II (he just wanted it for a quest or something) he signed off and a while after that someone came on his account. I said hi to him and asked for my II back and he said that he was not the real player but was a hacker who had used keylogger and was stealing my clannies items. He also spoke in pretty good english, where my clan friend only knows spanish and very little english that i know of. Then he signed off. Now, i have another friend who knows the pass for this account and tried logging it, but pass had been changed, so we suspected that it was a real hacker.
So the other day my other friend talked to the clannie who had been hacked and got his new password figured out after he had reset it again. He logged into the account and guess what, there was a nice II+7 there.... The clannie claims he bought it from his cousin for $15, but i think this is bs quite frankly. And either way he owes me an ii+7 right? My friend says that he can log in the account and give me the ii, but he also thinks this is dishonest. Also the clannie thinks we should split 50-50... What would you do?